That's what the ill-defined but well understood "they" say to do. The difficulty, or at least one of them comes from how vague a suggestion that is. One necessarily knows many things and few people are going to be interested in a thorough, in-depth expose on the manner in which I tie my shoe laces (negligently) or order pizza (like a boss).
Instead I'll detail what many Starcraft 2 players consider just a simple. The Four Gate. Or at least the version I use.
The Numbers
10 Pylon cut probe production
10 Gate resume and CB probe producton
13 Gas, 3 in once complete
15/@100 Gate Core
16 Pylon
18 Stop probe production
@100 core Warp Gate + Stalker
CB Core constantly
20 3x Gateway
20 Stalker (CB)
22 Proxy Pylon, rally stalkers
@ ~5:40 4x Stalker for 6 total, build another pylon at the ramp and go kill him
Simple. Direct. To the point. This warp gate is a bit faster than the standard but if executed cleanly you should have the numbers at the start. A toss going Robo will need perfect timing to get the Immortal out and even then it can be focused down by six stalkers and the four zealots you'll warp in at the front.
A few extra tips that should make things go more smoothly:
- Scout after gate or gas for Terran. You can push it and wait until after Core really for toss if you're confident or if the map isn't huge. Check those gases and if you can delay a barracks a little by harassing go ahead... but not the expensive of the build.
- Facing a Protoss you want a warp field that covers the ramp for a mid-ramp warp up if the bottom is force fielded. For Terran you just want something that will be covered by the vision from going up the ramp.
It used to be that you could four gate in every matchup all the way to Diamond, when Diamond was Master. That sounded good to me so I took a build from Dhal from the Penny-Arcade forums and got it down to a tee. It mostly worked. I'm currently a very middle class Platinum player with a 60-70% win percentage vs T and P using this build a vast majority of the time. But this build alone won't get you to diamond.
Its possible there are masters of micro that could get that high now, but I don't think so. The 4 gate is too well known to Zerg especially and Protoss are figuring out how to stop it. I use it in PvP and to the surprise of many, in PvT. Terrans often think you are simply three gate expanding. That's a powerful build but (as Day9 would say) four is oftentimes greater than three and it can simply kill an insufficiently prepared Terran.
Signs you should change what you're doing:
vs Protoss - Nothing. You're fairly committed. A defensive four gate can stop this but its a close thing at best if done correctly. Proxy gates and cannon rushes require special attention of course. But for the most part you can just blindly do it.
A Dark Templar rush can turn a victory into crushing defeat immediately. If the resistance to this attack is especially weak that can be a danger sign. Get into the base and see if one is coming up. If the warp tech was just late, you can kill off the pylons powering gates, securing the victory.
Therefore the best thing you can see when you scout is no gas. A marine only defense, such as a gas-less expand, is going to have a very very hard time stopping this even with multiple bunkers.
If a factory goes down, you're in good shape... it means no or few marauders and nothing out in numbers sufficient to stop this attack. A starport can indicate a banshee open, but cloak will be far from complete by the time the attack hits.
Scouting and Countering
So how does this lose? Its pretty simple. Don't die to it. This is pretty much an all-in build due to the number of workers you'll have. If you can't kill or severely damage your opponent you're going to be behind.
As a Protoss, denying the forward pylon is the best solution in my opinion. Rushing out two or three stalkers can buy precious seconds you need to get your Immortal out or finish your Shrine or Warp Gate Tech. A defensive Four Gate can hold this certainly and will generally have more probes even with a few losses.
As a Terran, marauders are the best counter, but two bunkers, or one with works waiting to repair at your ramp is pretty key. Even so, you might get zealots in your mineral line, so you have to be on guard.
So how do you tell its coming? The key tell is chronoboost energy in the Nexus. Normally a Protoss will spend this on probes early, investing in economy early to get a mid to late game advantage. Four gating require this on the Core to get the upgrade up ASAP. This variant is also a 10 gate, so if the gate is up very early and the Core is down with only one pylon in site (or better yet if you see a second pylon go down shortly after the Core) it could be this four gate.
The biggest tell? Four gates.
| THERE. ARE. FOUR. GATES! |
Hide your probe or SCV in the base. This variant ignores the zealot but even so your SCV or probe should be perfectly safe until the stalker comes out. The stalker will likely catch it, but to be on time gates 2-4 have to go down promptly and can't wait for the stalker to clear out every nook and/or cranny. If you can keep it alive for a short amount of time, you can probably see them go down... or delay them so the attack is weaker. There should be at most two pylons to power the gates after all.
This is a fairly simple build but one that wins in lower leagues. I'll be trying to apply the same general framework to more sophisticated builds as I get the hang of this blogging thing

